metal and asphalt roof

by






Metal and Asphalt Roof: A Comprehensive Comparison



Metal and Asphalt Roof: A Comprehensive Comparison

Choosing the right roofing material for your home is a significant decision, impacting not only its curb appeal but also its protection from the elements, energy efficiency, and overall value. Two of the most popular options available to homeowners today are metal and asphalt roofing. Both offer distinct advantages and disadvantages, making the selection process a bit challenging. This comprehensive guide aims to provide you with a detailed comparison of metal and asphalt roofs, covering everything from cost and durability to installation and environmental impact, empowering you to make an informed decision that best suits your needs and budget.

Understanding Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most commonly used roofing material in North America, largely due to their affordability and ease of installation. They consist of a fiberglass or organic mat saturated with asphalt and then coated with mineral granules. These granules protect the asphalt from UV rays and add color and texture to the roof.

Types of Asphalt Shingles

Within the realm of asphalt shingles, there are primarily three main types, each offering a different level of durability, aesthetics, and cost:

3-Tab Shingles

3-tab shingles are the most basic and economical type of asphalt shingle. They are characterized by their uniform, flat appearance and are relatively lightweight. While they are an affordable option, their lifespan is generally shorter compared to other asphalt shingle types, typically lasting 15-20 years. They also offer less wind resistance, making them susceptible to damage in areas with high winds.

Architectural Shingles (Dimensional Shingles)

Architectural shingles, also known as dimensional shingles, are a step up from 3-tab shingles in terms of both aesthetics and performance. They feature a multi-layered design that creates a more textured and dimensional look, mimicking the appearance of wood shakes or slate. Architectural shingles are also thicker and heavier than 3-tab shingles, offering improved durability and wind resistance. Their lifespan typically ranges from 25 to 30 years.

Luxury Shingles

Luxury shingles represent the premium tier of asphalt shingles. They are designed to replicate the look of high-end roofing materials like slate or tile, offering exceptional aesthetics and durability. Luxury shingles are typically the thickest and heaviest asphalt shingles, providing superior wind resistance and impact resistance. They often come with extended warranties and can last for 30 years or more. However, their higher cost makes them a more significant investment.

Advantages of Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles offer several advantages that contribute to their popularity:

  • Affordability: Asphalt shingles are the most cost-effective roofing material option.
  • Ease of Installation: Asphalt shingles are relatively easy to install, reducing labor costs.
  • Availability: Asphalt shingles are widely available from roofing suppliers and contractors.
  • Variety of Styles and Colors: Asphalt shingles come in a wide range of styles and colors to suit different architectural styles and homeowner preferences.
  • Good Fire Resistance: Asphalt shingles offer good fire resistance, providing a degree of protection against fire hazards.

Disadvantages of Asphalt Shingles

Despite their advantages, asphalt shingles also have some drawbacks:

  • Shorter Lifespan: Compared to metal roofs, asphalt shingles have a shorter lifespan, requiring more frequent replacement.
  • Susceptibility to Damage: Asphalt shingles can be damaged by extreme weather conditions such as high winds, hail, and UV exposure.
  • Lower Energy Efficiency: Asphalt shingles tend to absorb heat, which can increase cooling costs in warmer climates.
  • Environmental Impact: Asphalt shingles are made from petroleum-based products and contribute to landfill waste when replaced.

Exploring Metal Roofing

Metal roofing has gained significant popularity in recent years, driven by its durability, longevity, and energy efficiency. Metal roofs are typically made from materials such as steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc. They are available in a variety of styles, including standing seam, metal shingles, and metal tiles.

Types of Metal Roofing

The world of metal roofing offers a diverse range of options, each with its unique characteristics and benefits:

Standing Seam Metal Roofing

Standing seam metal roofing is considered the premium option in the metal roofing category. It consists of wide, flat panels that are joined together with raised seams, creating a clean, modern, and aesthetically pleasing look. Standing seam roofs are known for their exceptional durability, weather resistance, and long lifespan. The concealed fastener system eliminates exposed screws or nails, minimizing the risk of leaks and corrosion. This type of roofing is ideal for both residential and commercial buildings and is a popular choice for those seeking a high-performance and visually appealing roofing solution.

Metal Shingles

Metal shingles offer the aesthetic appeal of traditional shingles with the added benefits of metal roofing. They are designed to mimic the look of asphalt shingles, wood shakes, or slate tiles, providing a variety of styles to complement different architectural designs. Metal shingles are typically made from steel or aluminum and are coated with a protective finish to resist corrosion and fading. They offer excellent durability, wind resistance, and fire resistance, making them a long-lasting and reliable roofing option.

Metal Tiles

Metal tiles provide a unique and elegant roofing solution, replicating the look of clay or concrete tiles. They are typically made from steel or aluminum and are available in a variety of colors and textures. Metal tiles are lightweight, durable, and fire-resistant, offering superior protection compared to traditional tile roofing. They are also resistant to cracking, fading, and insect damage, making them a low-maintenance option. Metal tiles are a popular choice for homeowners seeking a distinctive and long-lasting roofing solution.

Corrugated Metal Roofing

Corrugated metal roofing is a more economical option compared to standing seam or metal shingles. It consists of metal sheets that have been rolled into a wavy pattern, creating a series of ridges and grooves. Corrugated metal roofs are lightweight, durable, and easy to install, making them a popular choice for agricultural buildings, sheds, and other outbuildings. While they may not offer the same aesthetic appeal as other metal roofing options, they provide excellent protection against the elements and are a cost-effective solution for many applications.

Advantages of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing offers a compelling set of advantages:

  • Long Lifespan: Metal roofs can last 40-70 years or even longer, significantly outperforming asphalt shingles.
  • Durability: Metal roofs are highly resistant to extreme weather conditions, including high winds, hail, and fire.
  • Energy Efficiency: Metal roofs reflect solar heat, reducing cooling costs in warmer climates.
  • Low Maintenance: Metal roofs require minimal maintenance, saving homeowners time and money.
  • Environmentally Friendly: Metal roofs are recyclable, reducing landfill waste.

Disadvantages of Metal Roofing

Despite the numerous benefits, metal roofing also has some drawbacks:

  • Higher Initial Cost: Metal roofs typically have a higher upfront cost compared to asphalt shingles.
  • Installation Complexity: Metal roof installation requires specialized skills and expertise.
  • Noise: Metal roofs can be noisier than asphalt shingles during rain or hail storms.
  • Denting: While durable, metal roofs can be susceptible to denting from large hailstones or falling debris.

Cost Comparison: Metal vs. Asphalt

The cost of a new roof is a primary consideration for most homeowners. Both material costs and installation labor contribute significantly to the overall price tag. A head-to-head comparison reveals substantial differences between asphalt and metal roofing.

Asphalt Shingle Cost

Asphalt shingles generally represent the more budget-friendly choice for roofing. The price is influenced by the type of shingle chosen (3-tab, architectural, or luxury) and the complexity of the roof structure. On average, the cost of an asphalt shingle roof can range from $3.50 to $5.50 per square foot installed. This includes the cost of materials, labor, and removal of the old roofing system.

Metal Roofing Cost

Metal roofing typically commands a higher initial investment than asphalt shingles. The cost is influenced by the type of metal used (steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc), the style of roofing (standing seam, metal shingles, or metal tiles), and the complexity of the installation. On average, the cost of a metal roof can range from $9.00 to $16.00 per square foot installed, and in some cases, even higher for premium materials like copper. This premium is justified by the roof’s extended lifespan, superior durability, and potential energy savings over the long term.

Long-Term Cost Considerations

While asphalt shingles may have a lower upfront cost, it’s important to consider the long-term costs associated with each roofing material. Asphalt shingles have a shorter lifespan than metal roofs, meaning they will need to be replaced more frequently. This repeated replacement cost can eventually offset the initial savings. Metal roofs, with their extended lifespan and minimal maintenance requirements, can prove to be a more cost-effective solution in the long run. Factors like energy savings from metal’s reflective properties should also be factored into the lifetime cost equation.

Durability and Lifespan

One of the most significant differentiators between metal and asphalt roofing lies in their durability and lifespan. A roof’s ability to withstand the elements and provide long-lasting protection is a crucial consideration for homeowners.

Asphalt Shingle Durability and Lifespan

Asphalt shingles are generally durable and can withstand typical weather conditions. However, they are susceptible to damage from extreme weather events such as high winds, hail, and UV exposure. Over time, the asphalt can dry out and crack, leading to granule loss and eventual roof failure. The lifespan of asphalt shingles typically ranges from 15 to 30 years, depending on the type of shingle and the climate.

Metal Roofing Durability and Lifespan

Metal roofs are renowned for their exceptional durability and longevity. They are highly resistant to extreme weather conditions, including high winds, hail, and fire. Metal roofs are also resistant to cracking, rotting, and insect damage. With proper installation and maintenance, a metal roof can last 40-70 years or even longer. This extended lifespan makes metal roofing a long-term investment that can significantly increase the value of your home.

Impact of Climate

The climate in your region can significantly impact the lifespan of both asphalt and metal roofs. In areas with extreme temperatures and high UV exposure, asphalt shingles may degrade more quickly. Metal roofs, on the other hand, tend to perform well in a variety of climates, with their reflective properties helping to reduce cooling costs in warmer regions and their durability standing up to harsh winter conditions.

Installation Process

The installation process for asphalt and metal roofs differs significantly. Understanding these differences is crucial for ensuring a proper and long-lasting roof installation.

Asphalt Shingle Installation

Asphalt shingle installation is a relatively straightforward process that can be completed by experienced roofing contractors. The process typically involves removing the old roofing material, installing a waterproof underlayment, and then nailing the asphalt shingles to the roof deck. Proper overlapping and sealing of the shingles are essential to prevent leaks. While seemingly simple, improper installation can lead to premature failure, so hiring a qualified professional is crucial.

Metal Roofing Installation

Metal roofing installation is more complex than asphalt shingle installation and requires specialized skills and expertise. The process involves careful measurement and cutting of the metal panels, as well as the use of specialized tools and fasteners. Proper sealing and flashing are crucial to prevent leaks and ensure the roof’s long-term performance. Because of the complexity and precision required, metal roof installation should only be performed by experienced contractors who are familiar with the specific type of metal roofing being installed.

DIY vs. Professional Installation

While it may be tempting to save money by installing a roof yourself, it’s generally not recommended, especially for metal roofing. Improper installation can void warranties and lead to costly repairs down the line. Hiring a professional roofing contractor ensures that the job is done correctly, safely, and in accordance with building codes. Professional installers also have the necessary insurance and licensing to protect you from liability in case of accidents or damage.

Energy Efficiency

In today’s world, energy efficiency is a growing concern for homeowners. Choosing a roofing material that can help reduce energy consumption and lower utility bills is a smart investment.

Asphalt Shingle Energy Efficiency

Standard asphalt shingles tend to absorb heat, which can increase cooling costs in warmer climates. However, there are now reflective asphalt shingles available that can help to reduce heat absorption. These shingles are coated with special granules that reflect sunlight, reducing the amount of heat that enters your home. While reflective asphalt shingles offer some energy savings, they are generally not as energy-efficient as metal roofs.

Metal Roofing Energy Efficiency

Metal roofs are highly energy-efficient due to their reflective properties. They reflect a significant portion of the sun’s rays, reducing the amount of heat that enters your home. This can lead to lower cooling costs in warmer climates and a more comfortable indoor environment. Metal roofs can also be installed with insulation, further enhancing their energy efficiency. Some metal roofs qualify for energy efficiency tax credits, making them an even more attractive option for homeowners.

Impact on HVAC Systems

The energy efficiency of your roof can have a significant impact on your heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems. A roof that absorbs a lot of heat will put more strain on your air conditioner, leading to higher energy bills and a shorter lifespan for your HVAC system. A reflective roof, on the other hand, can help to reduce the load on your HVAC system, saving you money and extending the life of your equipment.

Environmental Impact

Choosing a roofing material with a minimal environmental impact is becoming increasingly important for environmentally conscious homeowners.

Asphalt Shingle Environmental Impact

Asphalt shingles are made from petroleum-based products and contribute to landfill waste when replaced. The manufacturing process also involves the use of fossil fuels, which contributes to greenhouse gas emissions. While some asphalt shingles are recyclable, the recycling infrastructure is not yet widely available. As a result, most asphalt shingles end up in landfills, where they can take hundreds of years to decompose.

Metal Roofing Environmental Impact

Metal roofs are a more environmentally friendly option than asphalt shingles. Metal roofs are recyclable, meaning they can be reused to create new products. The manufacturing process is also generally less energy-intensive than the manufacturing of asphalt shingles. Metal roofs can also help to reduce energy consumption, which further reduces their environmental impact. Some metal roofs are made from recycled materials, making them an even more sustainable choice.

Life Cycle Assessment

A life cycle assessment (LCA) is a comprehensive analysis of the environmental impacts of a product throughout its entire life cycle, from raw material extraction to manufacturing, transportation, use, and disposal. LCAs of asphalt and metal roofs have shown that metal roofs generally have a lower environmental impact over their lifespan due to their durability, recyclability, and energy efficiency.

Aesthetics and Style

The aesthetic appeal of your roof is an important factor to consider when choosing a roofing material. Your roof contributes significantly to the overall curb appeal of your home.

Asphalt Shingle Aesthetics

Asphalt shingles are available in a wide range of styles and colors to suit different architectural styles and homeowner preferences. 3-tab shingles offer a uniform, flat appearance, while architectural shingles provide a more textured and dimensional look. Luxury shingles can mimic the look of slate or tile, offering a high-end aesthetic. With so many options available, you can easily find asphalt shingles that complement your home’s design.

Metal Roofing Aesthetics

Metal roofing offers a clean, modern, and sophisticated look. Standing seam metal roofs are particularly popular for their sleek lines and contemporary style. Metal shingles and tiles can mimic the look of traditional roofing materials like wood shakes, slate, and clay tiles, providing a variety of aesthetic options. Metal roofs are also available in a wide range of colors, allowing you to customize the look of your home.

Matching Your Home’s Architecture

When choosing a roofing material, it’s important to consider the architectural style of your home. Asphalt shingles are a versatile option that can complement a wide range of architectural styles, from traditional to modern. Metal roofs are particularly well-suited for contemporary homes, but they can also be used on other styles to create a unique and stylish look. Consider the color, texture, and style of the roofing material and how it will complement the overall design of your home.

Maintenance and Repair

All roofs require some level of maintenance and repair over their lifespan. Understanding the maintenance requirements of asphalt and metal roofs is important for ensuring their long-term performance.

Asphalt Shingle Maintenance

Asphalt shingles require regular maintenance to prevent damage and extend their lifespan. This includes inspecting the roof for missing or damaged shingles, cleaning moss and algae growth, and trimming overhanging tree branches. Minor repairs can often be done yourself, but major repairs should be handled by a professional roofing contractor.

Metal Roofing Maintenance

Metal roofs require minimal maintenance. They are resistant to moss and algae growth and do not require regular cleaning. However, it’s important to inspect the roof periodically for any signs of damage, such as dents or scratches. Minor scratches can be touched up with paint, but more significant damage may require professional repair.

Preventive Measures

Taking preventive measures can help to extend the lifespan of both asphalt and metal roofs. This includes keeping gutters clean to prevent water damage, trimming overhanging tree branches to prevent them from falling on the roof, and avoiding walking on the roof unnecessarily. Regular inspections can also help to identify potential problems early on, preventing them from escalating into more serious issues.

Resale Value

The type of roofing material you choose can impact the resale value of your home. A durable and aesthetically pleasing roof can be a significant selling point for potential buyers.

Impact on Home Value

A new roof can increase the value of your home, especially if it’s a high-quality material like metal. Metal roofs are seen as a premium roofing option and can add significant curb appeal to your home. While asphalt shingles can also increase your home’s value, the impact is generally not as significant as with metal roofing.

Buyer Perception

Potential buyers often perceive metal roofs as being more durable, energy-efficient, and long-lasting than asphalt shingles. This can make your home more attractive to buyers and potentially command a higher selling price. A well-maintained roof of any material demonstrates pride of ownership and reduces concerns about immediate repair costs for the buyer.

Return on Investment (ROI)

While metal roofs have a higher upfront cost, they can offer a better return on investment (ROI) in the long run. Their extended lifespan and minimal maintenance requirements can save you money over time. Additionally, the increased resale value of your home can help to recoup the initial investment. While asphalt shingles have a lower upfront cost, their shorter lifespan and higher maintenance requirements may result in a lower ROI.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Choosing between metal and asphalt roofing is a complex decision that depends on your individual needs, budget, and preferences. Asphalt shingles offer affordability and a wide range of styles, while metal roofs provide durability, longevity, and energy efficiency. Consider the long-term costs and benefits of each material, as well as your climate, architectural style, and personal preferences. By carefully weighing the pros and cons of each option, you can make an informed decision that will provide your home with lasting protection and value.